Surprise

Chapter 8

The photograph showed a fundraiser I remembered clearly.

Lily had been six. She spent the afternoon handing out paper flowers while my mother’s former patients told her stories about Grandma Rose. Clara had volunteered at the welcome table. Victor, whom she introduced as a cousin, had carried supplies.

I had thanked them both.

The memory made me sit down.

Naomi pulled the records from that fundraiser. Guests had given through cards, online forms, and a locked donation box. The box held cash and checks until the board treasurer counted them that evening.

“The totals balanced,” Naomi said.

“Who took the box to the office?”

We found the sign-out sheet. Clara and Victor had offered to help carry it. The treasurer had met them at the office door and counted the contents with another board member.

“If they took anything, it would have been before the box reached the office,” I said.

“Or the note is trying to send us in the wrong direction,” Naomi answered.

I gave the photograph to Detective Harris. She asked us not to question Victor ourselves.

The next day, Harris interviewed the person who had left the envelope. She did not tell us the name, but she said the information was worth checking. She also asked for the fundraiser’s guest list and any photographs taken that afternoon.

Evelyn Price had plenty. She had carried a camera because she disliked depending on her phone. She brought a folder of printed pictures to the clinic and helped Naomi identify the people in them.

In one, Victor stood beside the donation box. In another, he held it while Clara opened the lid to “straighten the envelopes.” I remembered her doing that in front of guests. At the time, it had looked helpful.

The original total still balanced with the forms we had received. Harris explained that an unrecorded cash gift could have disappeared without changing that total.

We could not say whether one had. We gave her everything and let her continue.

I struggled with that waiting. Each morning I took Lily to school, went to the clinic, and wondered what Clara had done during the months she sat at our family dinners.

One afternoon, Lily caught me looking at her while she read.

“You’re doing the worried face,” she said.

“What face?”

“The one where your eyebrows try to hold hands.”

I laughed despite myself.

“I’m thinking about work.”

“Do you want me to read to you?”

“Yes.”

She read three pages of her fox book while I listened. She had reached the part where the fox found its way home. For those few minutes, that was enough.

Later, Dad told me he had started seeing a counselor. Clara had made him doubt his own memory and judgment, and he wanted help understanding how he had let that happen.

“I used to think admitting I was fooled would make me look weak,” he said. “Now I’m tired of pretending I wasn’t.”

I was glad he told me. We still had hard conversations ahead, but he had begun having them.

Two weeks later, Harris called. Victor had given a statement. He said Clara had asked him to help with the previous fundraiser because she wanted access to donor information. He claimed he had not taken money, but he admitted that he later helped her draft the false party invitations.

“He says she promised to pay him from donations,” Harris told me.

“Does that mean he believed the party was legitimate?”

“He says he did at first. We’re checking that against his messages.”

She had also traced Lily’s refund cash. Clara had handed it to Victor shortly after leaving the clinic. He had used part of it to pay for printing the invitations and kept the rest.

Clara’s story about buying shoes with the refund had been false. She had used Dad’s card for the shoes and Lily’s money to fund the scheme.

I told Dad. He listened without interrupting.

“Do they know whether she took donations last year?” he asked.

“Not yet.”

He looked toward the photograph of Mom on his shelf.

“She trusted me with the foundation after she died. I let Clara walk into it.”

“You’re helping stop her now.”

“I know. I wish I’d done it sooner.”

Before I could answer, my phone rang again. It was Ms. Torres.

“The court has set a hearing about the document Clara filed,” she said. “Your father can explain what he was shown when he signed. The bank has also given us a copy of the access request.”

Dad straightened.

“I’ll be there.”

“There’s one more thing,” Ms. Torres said. “Clara’s lawyer says she wants to offer repayment and ask the prosecutor for a negotiated resolution.”

I looked at Lily’s drawing on the wall.

May you like

Repayment would help the people she had taken from. It would not erase the way Lily had asked whether needing glasses had caused trouble.

“We’ll hear what she’s offering,” I said. “Lily’s care and the foundation’s records have to be part of the truth.”

Related Stories

Other posts