Surprise

Chapter 6

I had never felt guilty for pulling my sister out of a burning building.

I had felt pain. Anger sometimes, though never at Vanessa for surviving. I had felt grief for the life my skin had before. But I had paid for Willowmere because my sister cried when she thought she would lose it.

I told Ethan that.

“I thought so,” he said. “Vanessa knows now too.”

“How did you find out Mom said it?”

“Vanessa showed me messages. Your mother kept telling her she didn’t need to thank you because paying was how you made peace with what happened.”

I rubbed my forehead.

“What did Mom say I needed to make peace with?”

“She never said.”

I knew the answer might not matter. Mom had turned a gift into something Vanessa could accept without feeling grateful. That had made it easier for both of them to ignore what they asked of me.

Ethan offered to send the messages. I asked him to keep them for now.

“I’ve seen enough today,” I said.

“I understand.”

On Monday, Lena sent the final account for Willowmere. The new couple’s booking reduced my cancellation loss. I would still lose a substantial amount, but less than I had feared.

Vanessa came over that evening with a notebook.

She had listed what she could pay each month without missing her rent or leaving Ethan responsible for it. The amount was modest. She had not written down an impossible promise to impress me.

“I checked my budget,” she said. “I can start next month.”

I showed her Lena’s figures.

“You can cover half of the remaining loss,” I said. “I made the decision to cancel. I’ll carry the other half.”

“That’s too generous.”

“It’s what I can live with. I don’t want every visit to turn into an argument about money.”

Vanessa looked at the page. “Then I’ll pay half.”

We wrote down the amount and schedule. I emailed her a copy. It felt awkward doing that with my sister, but clear terms gave us one less thing to fight over.

Afterward, she asked if we could talk about the hospital.

I made tea.

She described standing outside my room with Mom, holding a bunch of flowers she had bought from the hospital shop. Mom had told her I was not ready to see her.

“That part might have been true that day,” I said. “I was barely awake.”

“Mom said you couldn’t stand the sight of me.”

“I never said that.”

Vanessa traced the rim of her cup.

“I was ashamed of being relieved it wasn’t me in the bed,” she admitted.

“I would have wanted you out of that bed.”

“I know. I didn’t know it then.”

I told her about the surgeries and the long months when every ordinary thing took practice. I had learned to wash my hair without hurting my neck. I had learned to leave the house when strangers might stare.

“I stopped inviting you some days,” I said. “I thought my face upset you.”

“It did upset me,” she answered. “Because I remembered what you went through. I made that your problem instead of telling you how I felt.”

We were quiet for a while.

Then she asked, “Could I go to a support group with you sometime?”

“I don’t attend one now. I have friends who’ve been through burns. I could ask whether they have a family meeting.”

“I’d like that.”

I appreciated that she asked to learn, rather than asking me to make her feel forgiven.

That week, Mom began calling us both. Neither of us answered immediately. Vanessa told me she wanted to speak to her after she understood what she needed to say.

On Thursday, I met Mom at Renee’s house. Vanessa came too. Renee had agreed to be there because we all trusted her to stop the conversation if it became cruel.

Mom sat in an armchair, hands folded.

Vanessa placed the old hospital message on the coffee table.

“Why didn’t you show me this?” she asked.

Mom stared at the screen.

“I was afraid you’d feel responsible and rush to Claire before you were ready.”

“I already felt responsible.”

“I know that now.”

“Then why tell me Claire wished I’d come back inside?” Vanessa asked.

Mom looked at me. “I thought she was angry.”

“You told me you knew what I felt,” I said. “You never asked.”

Mom began to cry. For years, I had responded to her tears by softening what I said. I stayed quiet this time so she could answer.

“I couldn’t bear what happened to your face,” she said at last. “Every time I saw you, I saw how close I came to losing both of you.”

“That was frightening,” I said.

“It was.”

“And you made me feel ashamed of the face that survived.”

She covered her mouth.

Vanessa shifted beside me. “You told me Claire’s gift came from guilt. You made it easier for me to take her money and shut her out.”

“I wanted your wedding to be perfect.”

“You wanted it to look perfect,” Vanessa said.

Mom looked from one daughter to the other.

“What do you want me to do?”

“Tell us what you did without explaining it away,” I said.

Mom took a long breath.

“I kept Claire’s message from you, Vanessa. I told you something about her feelings that she never said. And I helped you ask her to leave the reception because I couldn’t face what her scars reminded me of.”

I looked at her for a long time.

“Thank you for saying it.”

Mom reached toward me. I was not ready to take her hand.

Before we left, she asked whether we would have dinner with her the following week.

“I don’t know yet,” I said.

Vanessa gave the same answer.

Outside, my sister stood beside me on Renee’s porch.

May you like

“I think that’s the first time we’ve both said no to her,” she said.

“It won’t be the last.”

Related Stories

Other posts